Germany’s historical ambition to establish dominance in Central Europe has taken many forms, from the German Empire (1871-1918) to the more subtle yet equally potent Mitteleuropa strategy.

Continue reading after the video.

Video is subtitled in English, German and Polish. Choose the language that suits you.

In a compelling lecture, Professor Grzegorz Kucharczyk, a distinguished scholar of 19th and 20th-century German political thought and a member of the Polish Academy of Sciences, dissects the historical parallels between past German imperial ambitions and present-day policies. His analysis unveils how the structures of the German Empire and the Mitteleuropa concept continue to influence the European Union today.

For those intrigued by how history shapes modern geopolitics, Professor Kucharczyk’s lecture is an essential listen. Below is an article summarizing his insights, shedding light on the historical foundations of Germany’s influence and the challenges it faces in sustaining its dominance.

The German Empire: A Blueprint for Power

The German Empire, established in 1871 under Prussian leadership, was not a unitary state but a federation of semi-autonomous entities. Despite this apparent decentralization, Prussia wielded overwhelming power, using its demographic and economic dominance to control the empire’s policies. The system created a façade of sovereignty for smaller German states while central authority remained firmly in Berlin’s hands.

Key mechanisms of German control over eastern and central European countries included:

Economic leverage – Prussia contributed the most to the empire’s budget, ensuring its dominance in decision-making.
Political engineering – The Bundesrat (upper house) was structured to give Prussia a blocking majority, effectively dictating policy.
Soft power projection – Germany cultivated an international image of modernity and efficiency, winning admiration from elites in Britain and the U.S.

These historical structures bear a striking resemblance to the power dynamics within the European Union, where Germany, through economic and bureaucratic influence, plays a dominant role while maintaining an image of collaborative leadership.

Mitteleuropa: A Strategy of Cultural and Economic Domination

The concept of Mitteleuropa—meaning “Central Europe”—gained prominence during World War I through the works of Friedrich Naumann. His 1915 book Mitteleuropa outlined a vision where Germany would not outright conquer its neighbors but would achieve dominance through economic integration and cultural influence.

Instead of forced Germanization, Naumann proposed a more sophisticated strategy:

Economic dependency – Creating a system where Central European nations relied on Germany for trade and industry.
Cultural influence – Promoting German philosophy and administrative models as the gold standard for governance and intellectual life.
Political subjugation under the guise of cooperation – Encouraging local governance but within a framework that served German strategic interests.

This strategy echoes in today’s EU dynamics, where German leadership is framed as a responsibility rather than dominance, yet Berlin effectively sets the economic and policy agenda for much of Europe.

Challenges to German Influence in the 21st Century

While Germany continues to exert significant influence in Central Europe, it faces growing obstacles:

Internal Economic and Social Crisis

The German economy, long reliant on cheap Russian energy and manufacturing exports, faces stagnation due to rising costs and global competition. Political fragmentation is evident, with the rise of parties like AfD reflecting public discontent. Societal divisions between former East and West Germany persist, with economic disparities fueling resentment.

Shifts in Global Geopolitics

The United States, under leaders like Donald Trump, has questioned Germany’s role in NATO and European security.Brexit removed the UK as a counterbalance to German dominance within the EU. Poland and other Central European nations increasingly assert their own interests, resisting German-led federalization of the EU.

The Erosion of Germany’s Historical Narrative

Germany has invested heavily in shaping historical memory to reinforce its leadership role, such as through the House of Polish-German History. However, efforts to downplay Germany’s direct responsibility for World War II crimes in occupied Poland and shift the narrative towards “shared responsibility” face growing scrutiny. As awareness increases, resistance to Germany’s “moral leadership” in Europe is likely to grow.

Conclusion

Professor Grzegorz Kucharczyk’s lecture provides a crucial perspective on the continuity of German strategic ambitions. The structures and philosophies underpinning the German Empire and the Mitteleuropa concept are not relics of the past; they continue to shape European politics today.

While Germany remains the dominant force in the EU, its ability to maintain this position is increasingly challenged by economic struggles, shifting global power dynamics, and growing skepticism from Central European nations. The question remains: will Germany adapt to these realities, or will it double down on its historical patterns of influence under the guise of European unity?

For a deeper dive into this critical analysis, we highly recommend listening to the full lecture by Professor Grzegorz Kucharczyk, one of the foremost experts on German political thought. His insights provide an essential lens through which to understand the past, present, and future of Germany’s role in Europe.

“Trouble with Germany”

In “Kłopoty z Niemcami. Kulturkampf, Ostpolitik, Mitteleuropa,” (“Trouble with Germany”) historian Grzegorz Kucharczyk offers a profound analysis of Germany’s complex relationship with Europe, particularly focusing on its interactions with Poland and the Catholic Church. This work delves into the cultural and political dynamics that have shaped German history from the 19th century to the present, providing readers with valuable insights into the nation’s evolving identity.

Mitteleuropa 2.0: Germany’s Quiet Empire in the Heart of Europe [VIDEO]